Costello's Ace - WEST BABYLON


515 Montauk Hwy
West Babylon, NY 11704
Phone: 631-321-1316
Fax: 631-586-1512
Manager: Colleen Grover
Email: 14874@costellosace.com

Store Services/Niches

Expert Key Cutting
Computerized Paint Color Matching
Screen and Storm Window Repairs
Automotive Chip Key Cutting
Knife Sharpening
Mower Blade Sharpening
Chainsaw Sharpening
Assembly Available
Special Order – Over 200,000 Items Available

Store Hours
Monday to Friday 8:00a – 9:00p
Saturday 8:00a – 9:00p
Sunday 8:00a – 6:00p


Holiday Hours
New Years Day 10:00a – 4:00p
Easter 9:00a – 4:00p
Memorial Day 8:00a – 6:00p
Independence Day 8:00a – 6:00p
Labor Day 8:00a – 6:00p
Thanksgiving Eve 8:00a – 9:00p
Thanksgiving Closed
Black Friday 7:00a – 9:00p
Christmas Eve 9:00a – 6:00p
Christmas Closed
New Years Eve 9:00a – 6:00p
Store Manager
Manager: Colleen Grover

Costello’s West Babylon store is wonderful and reliable. I am a frequent shopper and Joe Schiano and Deanna always go out of their way for me.
– Rosalie K.

Whenever I need anything it seems like Joe S. is right there to help me out.
– Vincent G.