Costello's Ace Hardware of Garden City Park
2323 Jericho Turnpike
Garden City Park, NY 11040

516-280-7885

Fax: 631-863-0187

Managing Partner:
Scott Hicok

15110@costellosace.com

Facebook

Directions Local Ad AceHardware.comThe Supply Place
Scott Hicok
Scott Hicok
STORE HOURS
Sunday8:00am - 6:00pm
Monday8:00am - 9:00pm
Tuesday8:00am - 9:00pm
Wednesday8:00am - 9:00pm
Thursday8:00am - 9:00pm
Friday8:00am - 9:00pm
Saturday8:00am - 9:00pm

SPECIALTY BRANDS

  •  Suncast Sheds
google

What Our Customers Are Saying

Marc W.Jul 19, 2025

Very friendly. They have what you need. Reasonably priced. Order online and pick up 15 mins later.

Robert H.Jun 12, 2025

As usual my latest trip to Ace Hardware was met with a very helpful associate. He escorted me to get what I wanted and again followed up a few minutes later to make certain I got the items. I really like this store. Every time I go there everyone I have dealt with has been professional, knowledgeable and helpful. Great store!

Pat K.Mar 19, 2025

Mike at the Garden City store is quality - really good books. I arrived 10 mins after they had closed, I merely told him that I just wanted to pick up some paint. Mike said “I got you brother” - just top quality attitude that is seldom seen today, no-one is like that! Good man Mike - old school / real attitude - Ace lad - really felt obliged to give him a review. Total respect.

undefinedJan 5, 2025

What a super positive experience!! I don’t know the employees name, but the young man who helped me today was truly what we all need and love when getting help efficiently in any store. He was eager, attentive, super nice, and assured me the product would work perfectly. I had great peace of mind having him help me. I knew he knew what he was talking about. Give that man a raise! He’s an asset to your location. Kudos to the super nice employee of yours!

Nick “.Nov 25, 2022

I bought my medium Big Green Egg here years ago, and have been shopping here just about Bi-weekly for all the BGE accessories. Spices, rubs, BBQ equipment, charcoal. They got it all. The BGE Charcoal is hard to come by, but when it’s here I get a few bags. That’s really the only section i go to and I love it. Employees are great, store is clean. Prices are decent, obviously I’d like to pay less but in this day the prices go up, the size goes down. I also respect that they were closed thanksgiving. People shouldn’t work they should be home!